The Sisters offer many different 4 and 6 pint variety packs! Each of these packs was hand picked to go together. We also offer The Sister pick packs if you just can’t decide what to get. If you have allergies and certain flavor preferences for the Sisters pick feel free to indicate in notes!

Generic Ice Cream Pint

The Sisters Pick 4 Pack

Too many choices? Let the Sisters pick 4 top flavors and send you a surprise.

Already subscribed and you want to make a request for next month? Drop us a line.
Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Birthday Party Pack

Bronx Cheer, Overtime, Dirty Ann, Officer Bob.

Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

The Mini Anarchist

Chocolate Anarchy, Dirty Ann, Berry in Black, The Experience.

Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Fall Festivities

The perfect variety pack for when the weather gets colder.

Featuring Snap, Plain Jane, Nine to Five, and Whiner.

Learn More

Read more

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Taste of Vermont

Chocolate Anarchy, Crystal Blue Persuasion, I Want Candy with Chocolate, and Snap.

Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

variety pack stock photo

Lovers Remorse No More

The Experience, Plain Jane, Whiner, Black Velvet If You Please

The Best Valentines Present

Learn More

Read more

Generic Ice Cream Pint

The Sisters Pick 6 Pack

Too many choices? Let the Sisters pick 6 top flavors and send you a surprise.

Already subscribed and you want to make a request for next month? Drop us a line.
Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Make Your Own 6 Pack

For the headstrong who know what they like. Choose any 6 pints you please.

Already subscribed and you want to make a request for next month? Drop us a line.
Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Select options

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Farmer’s Delight

Chaste Anne, Raspberry Beret, Crystal Blue Persuasion, Berry in Black, Respect Your Elders, and I Really Love Your Peaches.

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Extra Vanilla

Plain Jane, I Want Candy, Snap, Officer Bob Special, Chaste Anne, and I Want Candy…with Chocolate.

Learn More

Read more

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Soccer Mom Special

Anarchy, I Really Love Your Peaches, Overtime, Whiner, Nine to Five, Snap.

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

Chocoholics

Chocolate Anarchy, Chocolate Safe Space, Dirty Ann, Black Velvet, I Want Candy… with Chocolate, and Bronx Cheer.

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

variety pack stock photo

Chocolate Lover’s Roulette

Chocolate Anarchy 2x, Chocolate Safe Space 2x

The Best Box of Chocolate For Valentines Day

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

variety pack stock photo

Valentine’s Chocolates

Chocolate Anarchy, Chocolate Safe Space, Dirty Ann, Black Velvet, Officer Bob, Bronx Cheer.

The Ultimate Box of Chocolate

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

View Cart Checkout Continue Shopping

It’s not you…. It’s us…..we’re at our order max for the week. Read the order FAQs.