The Sisters offer multiple 4 and 6 pint variety packs! Each variety pack is a hand-picked combination of flavors. If you’re overwhelmed by your options and can’t decide, we offer the Sister Pick Packs where we send you a surprise combination of flavors! Please indicate any allergies or flavor preferences in notes for the Sisters Pick Pack. 

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Chocoholics” Assorted Chocolate Ice Cream

This assortment is a chocolate lover’s dream come true. Perfect for sharing (if you must), it’s a decadent collection that’ll elevate any dessert spread to legendary status!

(more…)

Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Taste of Vermont” Farm Fresh Vermont Ice Cream

Ready to indulge in a true taste of Vermont? Our Farm Fresh Vermont Ice Cream package brings the flavors of the Green Mountain State straight to your doorstep!

(more…)

Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“The Sisters Pick 4 Pack” Assortment of Artisan Ice Cream Flavors

4 PACK
Too many choices? Let the Sisters pick 4 top flavors and send you a surprise.

Already subscribed and you want to make a request for next month? Drop us a line.
Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Birthday Party Pack” Birthday Party Ice Cream Assortment

Make your birthday bash a legendary affair with our Birthday Party Pack! This ice cream assortment is your ticket to flavor town, packed with a lineup that will blow your guests away.

(more…)

Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Make Your Own 4 Pack” Mail Order Ice Cream Varieties

4 PACK
For the headstrong who know what they like. Choose any 4 pints you please.

Already subscribed and you want to make a request for next month? Drop us a line.
Learn More

$48.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Select options

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Farmer’s Delight” Handmade Farm Fresh Ice Cream

Indulge in the creamy goodness of our Handmade Farm Fresh Ice Cream, where every scoop is a tribute to quality and authenticity. 

(more…)

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“The Sisters Pick 6 Pack” Assorted Ice Cream Favorites

Feeling overwhelmed by all the delicious choices? Let the Sisters do the hard work for you with our Assorted Ice Cream Favorites pack!

(more…)

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Make Your Own 6 Pack” Mail Order Ice Cream Assortment

6 PACK
For the headstrong who know what they like. Choose any 6 pints you please.

Already subscribed and you want to make a request for next month? Drop us a line.
Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Select options

Generic Ice Cream Pint

“Sisters’ Favorites” Best Selling Gourmet Ice Cream Flavors

6 PACK
Chocolate Anarchy, Tap That, I Want Candy with Chocolate, Raspberry Beret, Snap, and Respect Your Elders.

Learn More

$70.00 — or subscribe and save up to 5%Add to cart

View Cart Checkout Continue Shopping

It’s not you…. It’s us…..we’re at our order max for the week. Read the order FAQs.